Thursday, November 10, 2011

Unconventional Trust Building

The leadership gurus who authored Credibility: How Leaders Gain and Lose It and Why People Demand It  make a powerful statement: "Every time we follow someone we do not trust, we erode our self-esteem." Every single day my graduate studies push me to find answers to complicated questions.  How exactly do we build or rebuild trust? I reflected, explored and found at least one conceivable path for troubled relationships and organizations. Even though this path is fueled by one of the most basic foundations of human behavior, I found myself questioning it. Why would an easy answer come when I have struggled for answers in every other class?

Neuroeconomist Paul Zak draws on an idea moral philosopher, Adam Smith gave us when he said we are moral because we are social creatures. Regarding the market, Zak says: "I don't need a top down designer to tell everyone what to do. We know what to do. If I'm doing something wrong I'm going to know pretty soon because we are social creatures." Zak's research further indicates 98% of people reciprocate trustworthiness. If this is true and the individual whose trust is betrayed takes a knock in self-esteem, it makes sense why so many believe the worst in others.  Mistrust can be created by manipulators who do not produce the trust molecule and thereby have picked up on the cues of the majority who produce the molecule and because of our social nature respond with empathy and generosity only to discover we've been duped. Ouch!

Zak's earlier research on markets had shown that countries who were trustworthy were also prosperous.  From these studies he discovered the trust molecule oxytocin when given as a supplement induced greater generosity.  In another study he discovers oxytocin creates empathy and this is what makes us help others. Accordingly, empathy and morality walk hand in hand. Knowing the underpinnings of trust and morality means we can also understand how to create it. We can increase our oxytocin through dance, massage, prayer, and hugs.  Now many of these can be practiced in organizations to build trust, but as I grow wiser I think a sniff test is in order. What do I have in mind?




I have always admired huggers--especially when I wasn't one. Here is one story in which a wrong was committed and no excuses were accepted. Juan Mann's resiliency plan included offering free hugs.  In today's world of increased distrust it is no surprise (although it hits high on my absurd meter) Mann's free hugs were banned. Mann set down his free hugs sign and gathered 10,000 signatures of protest and was able to resume giving free hugs.




So, you want to build trust in your organization? Some days it will take everything from you to empathize and show patience to those who have been betrayed. On those days it seems fitting to start with respect and end with a hug.

Monday, October 31, 2011

Ethical Considerations

The second half of the semester is going to be a reading-intensive purview and mentally taxing application of ethics. As I refit my lens I notice I am already observing ethics in action. For instance I saw a fascinating documentary called Long Lance. This is the story the National Film Board of Canada introduces as, "Was he a black man, a white man, or an Indian chief? This documentary looks at legendary and fascinating impostor Chief Buffalo Child Long Lance."


Prior to entering this graduate program I likely would have seen this in a less balanced view, automatically assuming it more black and white than it is; in fact my educated focus is not on blaming the imposter but questioning the organization that produces a man who will lie (with community silence) to escape the racial confines of society.

For me, knowing that Long Lance did not use his notoriety to swindle others out of money or cause deliberate harm helps me see the situation more favorably.  He was a talented writer and made some progress for better treatment of Canadian Indian tribes. It seems his intent was right but his content was wrong, and like many unsuccessful leaders he couldn't figure out why people didn't like him. In the health world of cleansing and detoxing it is a known fact that a person cannot be cleaner than his or her environment. Can leaders authentically be pure in an impure organization?

Saturday, October 29, 2011

Organizational Communication (Semester Summary)

Organizations are a part of all our lives. Although we are often born into organizations and cultures, as individuals we do our best when we question our life purpose and our place in the organization. By doing so we recognize we have many choices in the organizations we join and the organizations we leave.

John O'Neill. The Man Who Knew. The man who saturated himself in knowledge, became an expert in his profession, and ultimately questioned the mission of his organization. O'Neill's communication style was interpreted through his flashy clothes, aggressiveness, and worldwide contacts. The verdict was O'Neill was not cut from the same clothe and he had sharp elbows. "You can get by with some sharper elbows for a while, but you need to be right a lot." James Kallstrom, former NY FBI director continues, "You can have those types of character traits -- you really need to have those to get the job done sometimes -- but there'll always be a comeuppance in bureaucracies if you exercise that too much and you don't restrain it."

The structure of the bureaucracy is described by the well-written text Strategic Organizational Communication in a Global Economy as one which is specialized, hierarchical, and centralized. For those individuals raised in societies with this structure it is seen as normal and natural. "As members of these societies mature, they learn that formal rules are necessary for the efficient operation of societies and organizations because they protect people from arbitrary or harmful treatment by more powerful people."

 
O'Neill's life-consuming expertise in counter terrorism led him to seek out a reorganization within the agency to draw more attention on the looming threat of Al-Qaeda. When he could find no internal support within the hierarchy and management of Louis Freeh and supportive, centralized associates such as Thomas Pickard, O'Neill's friends began to advise him to take his expertise to a field office. 
 
O'Neill did move to the New York office and worked for another career FBI person. His boss, James Kallstrom said, "I had a fairly low opinion of headquarters throughout my whole career. It seemed like, you know, the headquarters was a very negative place, where they would find a million reasons why you couldn't do something, as opposed to why you could do something. It was not the type of place where you always felt you were getting a lot of assistance." However, much to O'Neill's dismay, his reputation seemed to still influence the hierarchical decision makers choices during critical times.  In a painfully obvious manner such tasks were not assigned to John O'Neill, but to  agents who were not necessarily experts or as well versed in counter terrorism.

The semester text cites scholarly findings which, "found that when the environment is unstable and turbulent, the bureaucracy is too slow to adapt. Its formal structures, standard operating procedures, and centralized decision making limit its members' ability to recognized the need for change and make it inflexible when change is necessary." Robert Bryant, former FBI deputy director confirms, "The trouble with the FBI, it never knew what it knew. I mean, it had information, but it never got to the right places."





Watch The Man Who Knew on PBS. See more from FRONTLINE.

John O'Neill. The self-taught counter terrorism expert. The man who devoted his career and life to the FBI. The Man Who Knew. The man who spoke up. The man who was chased out of the FBI. 

Former colleague, Joe Cantamessa says,  "There is a difference between those people who spend time in an organization and are happy to make it to the top and have never rolled over a stone or created a problem or solved a problem, you know, just to carefully run through, and be there and be promoted. John was not like that."

No, John O'Neill was not like that. O'Neill spoke up. He told the hard truth. He consistently acted on his truth. Socrates advises us well in times of turmoil "All men's souls are immortal, but the souls of the righteous are immortal and divine." Many less resilient and hardy leaders have caved and fallen into mediocrity. As I read Socrates, people, organizations they can appear to do us harm but in truth the soul of a good person cannot be permanently tainted by the corruption of others.